An outstanding writeup and analysis

This is an outstanding writeup and analysis.
.

Reposted from Joseph Fournier

Part I of II: High Tech rarely equates with “Clean Tech”.

Contrary to what public relations specialists has paid the media to convince society that battery energy storage systems (BESS) are “Clean Tech”, I will argue that the opposite is true.

Note that my Doctorate Thesis was in electrochemical conversion & storage sciences.

While I rarely use the phrase “Clean Tech”, I propose for the sake of constructive argument that underground caverns best represent the best in class of “Clean Tech” solution for long duration energy storage.

These storage vessels include depleted oil & gas formations, salt caverns and aquifers and in United States alone, there is the capacity to store over 4,600 billion cubic feet (bcf) of natural gas, which is essential to carry the country through the winter season when demand greatly exceeds the daily production rate. (Open link ↗)

Note that 4,600 bcf of natural gas = 48 TWh = 48,000 GWh.

Note that the current energy storage capacity of lithium ion battery systems (Li-BESS) in United States is estimated at 45 GWh (Open link ↗).

In other words, there is 1000x more natural gas storage capacity than there is Li-BESS.

Considering that the gravimetric energy storage density of a standard Li-BESS is around 0.1 MWh per tonne, we would need to mine, refine and manufacture around 440 million tonnes of critical minerals to achieve an equivalent electrical energy storage capacity of 48 TWh in United States alone.

Of course, mining and refining of critical minerals is but one metric of environmental impact, but you get the drift.

Most common sense people would agree that environmental cleanliness must include a life cycle assessment of impacts on water, air and land.

When we consider the fact that the vast majority of natural gas storage areas are depleted oil & gas wells, these systems are truly prime examples of sustainability by virtue of the fact that they are recycled and repurposed underground environmental disturbances of legacy oil & gas production.

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 4

  1. Ray Freudenberg

    Excellent! I have also heard that cows are excellent mobile methane storage bladders. The best part? You don't need to bury them!

  2. Perry Roberts

    The Energy Transfer Bammel Storage Facility is a great example. I was always impressed with the management of the stored nat gas.

  3. Johann Holm

    Excellent... Well described and logical.

  4. Brad Bertoch

    Excellent analysis. Thank you!

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Comments are checked before they appear.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.