A primer on the Electrical Grid, and what happens when (and not…

A primer on the Electrical Grid, and what happens when (and not *if*) it fails.

A few excerpts below, far more in the link.

With many Western governments repeatedly warning to prepare for 3 to 7 day electrical outages, this is good information to understand.

===========================

“… Before starting: what a grid actually is.

Most people’s mental model of the electrical system holds up reasonably for a house and fails completely for a country,

– since a house delivers power when you throw a switch and cuts it when you stop paying,

– while a country performs a continuous balancing act sixty times a second in which generation tracks load within a hair of perfect and every device on the network is at once a load and a participant in voltage and frequency.

》 Nothing is stored anywhere, so the instant production and consumption diverge beyond a small margin, physics closes the gap by shedding something.

Three physical facts govern everything downstream of that.

● Frequency is a shared property of an interconnected area and it sags when load outruns generation, at which point plant trips itself off to avoid damage, which removes more generation and drops frequency further, so the last automatic step is underfrequency load shedding, meaning relays that dump blocks of customers to save the machine. …

● Voltage behaves differently because it is local and managed with reactive power, since pushing too much real power down a long line sags voltage at the far end and injecting reactive power lifts it again.

Modern inverter-based generation can do this, but only when configured and instructed to, and Spain’s problem was that too much of it was not behaving the way the operator’s model said it would, while voltage that climbs instead of falling kills just as fast because overvoltage trips plant and the trip is instantaneous.

● Inertia is the third and it has quietly drained away, given that a spinning coal or gas turbine resists a sudden frequency change the way a heavy flywheel resists a shove, whereas solar and wind inverters carry no mass and instead synthesize a response, which they increasingly do well but which remains software, and software can be misconfigured.

Grids built on a century of rotating metal are being rebuilt on power electronics at a pace nobody has attempted before, and the Iberian event shows what the transition looks like when a control assumption turns out to be wrong. …

Open link ↗

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 14

  1. Suman Kar

    More and more grids throughout the world are going digital. Do you think , considering the future we are headed towards, that manual grids are far safer?

  2. Tom KirkmanAuthor

    Suman Kar we need a return to *more* heavy spinning gas or coal turbines, and *fewer* inverters for wind and solar.

    At some point (probably soon), some very hard lessons will be learned.

  3. Suman Kar

    Tom Kirkman that's the generation side of things, what about the rest.
    When a grid is hijacked, it is mostly done by taking control of the IT company, then making changes to the firmware (if it's a serious hijack), which then sabotages or destroys physical components of the grids like relays.

    What I wanted to ask is this - How an old school Diesel tractor cannot be *hijacked* and forced for repairs (like they do in some famous tractor companies), similarly, is it not possible to build a grid that's manual and away from cyber attacks?

  4. Jeffrey Zarend, Open to work

    I've never understood load shedding. Where does it go?

    Good fiction read: Overload by Arthur Hailey

  5. Tom KirkmanAuthor

    Suman Kar it's possible, but not being done.

    Also, a few years ago in the U.S., there were numerous "penetration testing" attacks against electrical substations, shooting them with shotguns and high powered rifles, likely meant to gauge responses to shooting the substations.

    Combined simultanous attacks (either physical or successful IT hacking) against less than a dozen specific electrical substations in the U.S. would collapse most of the U.S. electric grid for days.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.