If it cannot be questioned, it is not science

If something cannot be questioned, it is the *opposite* of actual Science.

Asking questions is an integral part of actual Science.

Too often these days, dogma and inflexible ideologies are deliberately mislabelled as “Science”.

Or even worse, the laughable and mythical unicorn fantasy called “Settled Science”.

And thanks for the mention in your article, Armando Cavanha.
First time I’ve been compared with U.S. Energy Secretary Chris Wright.

.

Reposted from Armando Cavanha

Energy Transition – Science or Ideological Polarization?
Tom Kirkman
Ronald Stein
Fatih Birol

FROM THE THREAD

Comments 12

  1. Gerry Deagnon

    🤭😉🫡

  2. Aly Dhanji

    'Greenback' Science.

  3. Tom KirkmanAuthorreplying to Aly Dhanji

    Fact Checked: TRUE
    (Now give me money)

  4. Paul Wittrock

    Moving goal posts indeed. Energy "transition" is a private equity play wrapped in a virtue signalling value proposition fueled by a political revenue model. If the goal is truly to "save the planet," net lifecycle climate impact (and financial modeling) over minimum 75-100 years should drive our energy generation strategies.

    Net lifecycle climate impact should be the prevailing metric yet when nuclear is shown to be less than 25% of the impact of PV solar or wind generation, "too expensive" or "takes too long" are the knee jerk retorts. Yet when comparing nuclear's service life (75+ years) to solar or wind (12-15), nuclear is a veritable bargain. With global average build times past 5 decades of 7 years (China <5) for new plants, less for coal/nat gas conversions, NPP build time is only 30-40% longer than "renewables" for 4-5 times the service life. Further, when including battery storage to level up "renewables" base load to match nuclear the net impact of renewables increases dramatically (e.g. Tesla Megapak batteries, popular for utility grade implementations, have a standard 12 year, max 15 year warranty/service life).

  5. Tom KirkmanAuthorreplying to Paul Wittrock

    Thanks Paul Wittrock. In my view, most of the Climate Alarmism is *not* actually about the environment, but about grabbing government subsidies, and a wealth transfer.

    The leaders pushing Climate Alarmism are benefitting.

    Of course, there are multitudes of unquestioning "true believers" way further down the food chain that sincerely believe the scaremongering.

Keep reading

Enjoyed that?
Get the next one.

New posts on energy, projects and Weekend Science — straight to your inbox, without the algorithm.